• About
  • Article PDF
  • White Papers
  • Listening Tours​
  • Contact
  • Support Us
  • Advertising & Sponsorships
Tuesday, August 9, 2022
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
Times Of Entrepreneurship
Growth and Equity for a Changing World
Times Of Entrepreneurship
No Result
View All Result

To Get More Capital To Communities of Color, White Men in Finance Need to Cede Power

State Street’s Diversity Goals Should be Applauded not Scapegoated

by Nate Wong
November 12, 2021
in Finance
Reading Time: 5 mins read
0
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
fearless girl statue
Photo by Ahmer Kalam on Unsplash

Boston-based State Street, one of the largest investment firms in the world, has made bold plans to diversify its ranks, with a plan to triple the number of female and ethnic minority staff in senior roles by 2023. However, instead of reporting on this goal as an ambitious attempt to level the playing field within an overwhelmingly homogenous financial industry, news headlines rang out that the firm “will need permission to hire white men,” among other similar takes. Not only is this false, it has played into a dangerous narrative that has been catnip for culture wars, that the changes that move us toward a more equal society are unfair. That false narrative shouldn’t go unanswered.

Fairness and Equity are not the Same

The idea that fairness toward individuals and equity among groups are equally important needs to be re-examined. To rightly see how they’re different, we need to understand the context, including history, before we move forward. In this case, the simple act of hiring  a diverse workforce ultimately means reckoning with a legacy of societal and institutional structures that have promoted a financial industry in the U.S. dominated by white males at the expense of other groups. By baking these racist and sexist structures into candidate pipelines, organizational cultures, and advancement incentives, whether intentionally or not, the industry has impeded capital flow to Black and Latinx communities. Over time, this has contributed to the racial wealth gap in the United States, since overwhelmingly White asset managers innately did not know or understand communities that were not their own. They couldn’t adequately advocate for their inclusion. At its worst, the financial industry blocked progress, promoted concentration of wealth, and advocated for policies like redlining that made these preferences codified rules. This is the very definition of inequity. Addressing these historical wrongs means moving ahead with tangible actions and goals, as State Street has done.

Righting these wrongs will require people, many whom history has preferenced, to suspend their view of individual fairness or what some may call “power.” In their book, Power for All, pioneering researchers Julie Battilana and Tiziana Casciaro say that most people have deep-seated misconceptions about power. “Most people assume power is predetermined by personality or wealth, or that it’s gained by strong-arming others.” Thus, any act that’s perceived as an “assault” on power is met with an equal defiance. Yet Battilana and Casciaro offer a different definition of power as “the ability to influence someone else’s behavior. This influence is derived from having access to valued resources, which anyone can have, regardless of their income or status in life. Everyone has a resource to offer, so everyone has access to power.”

Companies that prioritize diversity emphasize resources in the form of talent, lived experience and skills that enable better work for groups or customers who’ve been historically excluded from finance and wealth accumulation. This talent often looks like the very communities that financial companies want to serve better. Inevitably, white men may find themselves in more fierce competition with those who have not historically been deemed their peers. Hence, the defensive reaction we’re seeing in media, and no doubt, in some boardrooms. It has nothing to do with fairness. The system has never been impartial or objective to individuals.

Teeth Behind the Pronouncement

A more nuanced look at State Street’s goal reveals real teeth behind its ambition. “Our [diversity hiring initiative] is now front and central for State Street — it’s on every senior executive’s scorecard,” said Jess McNicholas, the bank’s head of inclusion, diversity, and corporate citizenship in London. McNicholas is referring to accountability that “leaders have to demonstrate at their annual appraisals what they have done to improve female representation and the number of colleagues from ethnic-minority backgrounds.” If not, there are repercussions, including facing lower bonuses if these goals are not achieved. There’s no excuse anymore for a lack of qualified candidates or pipelines.

It requires work to shift the norm. Any management theorist knows that strong goals have to be clear, but also require an articulation of what success will look like and a mechanism to incent their teams to achieve them. This is what State Street has done. And they aren’t alone. Goldman Sachs has set goals of having Black and Latinx employees make up 7% and 9% of its vice president ranks, respectively, by 2025.  From a gender parity standpoint, Deutsche Bank has a goal of having women make up 30% of its senior executives by 2025, an increase of 6% from its current position.

Secret Diary of a Sustainable Investor

State Street’s efforts are part of a larger movement in the financial industry toward accountability for its larger role in society. The conversation is moving beyond shareholders to the needs of stakeholders, from employees to communities to the environment. Standards — teeth — that in State Street’s case turned its actions into catnip for the culture wars are necessary. Some of these non-financial goals around environmental, social, and governance-related impacts, known as ESG, may be controversial.

When there aren’t goals and standards, organizations instead use “loose half-measures, overly rosy forecasts” and the result is a false sense of security, as the former BlackRock executive Tariq Fancy has written in the widely-shared long essay, “The Secret Diary of a ‘Sustainable Investor’.” We can ill afford a false sense of security as the world faces crises of inequality and climate change. ESG is hard to implement, but there is a general acceptance that the rules need to change and standards are needed to guide this work further as many have been advocating for. The use of the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB) disclosure metrics (the Value Reporting Foundation) alongside those from Global Reporting Initiative show that this work requires organizational intentionality, industry transparency, and public accountability to move these non-financial goals forward, including the social part connected to diversity.

Lessons Learned

What we can learn from the State Street example is that goals require bold prioritization and trade-offs if they are truly worth it. So instead of being the anchor dragging along the seafloor as the tide shifts, we can change the narrative to a positive one, moving toward a culture of equality and fairness for all. Correcting past harms within Wall Street, which is at the heart of our current power structures, is worth the good trouble we’ll encounter along the way. 

Nate Wong is an adjunct professor at Georgetown University and focuses on reimagining capitalism for societal good. He has launched and grown impact units at Deloitte, Boston Consulting Group, and Georgetown.

 

For more inspiring stories, insights and actionable funding opportunities, subscribe to Times of E’s weekly newsletter, www.timesofe.com/introduction.
Tags: Nate WongState Street
Nate Wong

Nate Wong

Related Posts

Take Your IRR With A Grain Of Salt. It’s A Vanity Metric

Take Your IRR With A Grain Of Salt. It’s A Vanity Metric

by Seth Levine
May 11, 2022
0

Seth Levine I’m observing that IRR is a metric that is becoming an increasing focus in venture, replacing fund return...

collaged headshots of a man and woman

VC Spotlight: A Palestinian Venture Fund, Going Strong, Aims To Raise Another $15M 

by Elizabeth Macbride
April 25, 2022
0

Habib Hazzan and Ambar Amleh Name: Ibtikar Fund Location: Palestine Website: www.ibtikarfund.com Size: We are currently raising Ibtikar Fund II, which we are targeting...

Commentary: Authenticity Is Women’s Most Powerful Weapon in Raising Funds. Here’s How To Tap Into It.

Commentary: Authenticity Is Women’s Most Powerful Weapon in Raising Funds. Here’s How To Tap Into It.

by Allison Long Pettine
March 23, 2022
0

Allison Long Pettine Oh, I’m so sorry. Forgive me. You take the good seat. When women communicate with each other,...

VC Spotlight: Entrepreneur-Turned-Investor Lu Zhang Is On Her Third, $120M Fund

VC Spotlight: Entrepreneur-Turned-Investor Lu Zhang Is On Her Third, $120M Fund

by Elizabeth Macbride
March 11, 2022
0

Lu Zhang Name: Fusion Fund Location: Palo Alto, CA Website: https://www.fusionfund.com/ Size: I just launched Fund III last year. It...

Editor’s Note: Is Venture Capital Really a Tool for Broad Economic Development?

Editor’s Note: Is Venture Capital Really a Tool for Broad Economic Development?

by Elizabeth Macbride
February 23, 2022
0

Elizabeth Macbride Earlier this month, the National Venture Capital Association and the University of North Carolina’s Kenan Institute of Private...

blonde woman in black

Kizmet Impact Aims To Be One of the First Publicly Traded VC Funds

by Skyler Rossi
February 11, 2022
0

Marissa Bronfman Name: Kizmet Impact Capital Location: Toronto and Vancouver, Canada Web site: https://www.kizmetimpact.com Size: Raising its first $50M fund...

Subscribe to Times of E’s Free Weekly Newsletter

Learn about the emerging ecosystem of diverse founders

Popular

  • man in front of a tufted rug

    TikTok Craze Gets Real at a Brooklyn Rug Tufting Studio

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Venture Capital Returns Are More Skewed Than People Realize

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Commentary: Authenticity Is Women’s Most Powerful Weapon in Raising Funds. Here’s How To Tap Into It.

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Top 20 U.S. University Entrepreneurship Competitions, 2021

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • A City Of 66,000 Is At The Center Of An Audacious, $200M Attempt To Build A Tech Hub From Scratch

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Recent

woman leaning against a brick wall in a white jacket

Editor’s Note: Times of E is on a reduced publication schedule

June 23, 2022
Video: Armory Square Ventures’ Sawhney On The Rise of Upstate NY

Newsletter: Varsity Blues, redemption stories and women-led finance

June 23, 2022
Video: Armory Square Ventures’ Sawhney On The Rise of Upstate NY

Video: Armory Square Ventures’ Sawhney On The Rise of Upstate NY

June 19, 2022

Recommended

  • Health
  • Climate
  • Deep Tech
  • Finance
  • Education
  • Women Entrepreneurs
  • Mentorship
Pawlytics Uses Microchips To Help Homeless Pets’ Health

Pawlytics Uses Microchips To Help Homeless Pets’ Health

1 year ago
white bearded man in white shirt

Danish Startup Peaqs Aims To Create A Sandbox Platform To Train Entrepreneurs At University

1 year ago
  • About
  • Partner
  • Bespoke Research
  • Listening Tours​
  • Contact
  • Support Us
  • Privacy Policy

(703-966-7357)

© 2020 Mondial Publishing Inc. All Rights Reserved.

 
Facebook Twitter Linkedin
No Result
View All Result
  • Research
  • Finance
  • Women Entrepreneurs
  • New Builders
  • Ecosystem
  • Events
  • Newsletter
  • Editor’s Note

© 2022 Mondial Publishing Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
Free Download

Times of E Speaks with Jim McKelvey

Get exclusive insights on the future of entrepreneurship. 

Download Now

Support Times of E

Times of E covers the emerging ecosystem of diverse founders.

With your support of our journalism, you will receive our weekly newsletter and one of these resources for free: 

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?