• About
  • Article PDF
  • White Papers
  • Listening Tours​
  • Contact
  • Support Us
  • Advertising & Sponsorships
Monday, June 5, 2023
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
Times Of Entrepreneurship
Growth and Equity for a Changing World
Times Of Entrepreneurship
No Result
View All Result

Op-Ed: Fraudulent Fintech-Bank Partnerships Destroy Small Businesses

by David Levine and Stephen Michael
May 11, 2021
in Finance
Reading Time: 4 mins read
1
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

When banks and fintechs team up for the purpose of offering affordable, transparent and fair products, consumers and small businesses benefit. But when companies calling themselves fintechs use banks to enable unaffordable, usurious lending that non-bank lenders could not do legally directly, the results can be disastrous. 

It is these fraudulent bank partnerships that benefit most from a rule issued late last year by Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC). Congress has the opportunity to overturn that rule using the Congressional Review Act. It should do so.

Many states limit the interest rates on consumer loans, and some have civil or criminal usury caps that also apply to business loans. Nonbank lenders must comply with these laws, but nearly every state has exempted banks from their rate caps, and federal laws allow banks to “export” this lack of a rate cap to other states, preempting those states’ usury laws. Unfortunately, predatory lenders have found a small number of rogue banks that are willing to lend their name to enable truly shocking loan programs run by nonbank entities. 

The OCC’s rule prohibits courts from looking at the truth about who the lender is, preempting state usury caps as long as a bank is “named as the lender on the loan agreement.” It does not matter under the rule if the nonbank lender funds the loan and controls virtually every aspect of the loan program save a rubber stamp approval from the bank. Courts can’t look beyond the fine print.

Here’s how these relationships typically work: A lender helps identify borrowers to whom it wants to lend at rates above what their states permit. It makes a deal with a bank in another state, where such rates are allowed, to put up the money. Then the bank sells the lion’s share of the loan to the lender or a company connected to the lender, according to an investigation by the Wall Street Journal.

For example, the OCC’s rule is being actively used right now to preempt state usury laws and to defend one lender’s right to charge 268% APR on a $67,000 loan to a restaurant owner. Markisha and Carlos Swepson needed income after a long renovation process and a new baby. According to court documents, World Business Lenders offered a daily rate of .3575%, and the Swepsons did not understand how that translated into a shocking APR. The Swepsons dealt entirely with WBL, which collected the loan payments, but Axos Bank was listed as the lender. After the Swepsons fell behind, WBL refused to work with them and turned back to Axos to file a foreclosure action against the property that secured the loan. Axos Bank is now arguing that the court cannot look at whether WBL was just renting the Axos Bank charter: “as recently made clear by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, even such arrangements are proper,” and even if the loan were immediately assigned to WBL, “the OCC’s final rule would permit the same interest rates and fees to be charged by WBL as by Axos Bank.”

These rent-a-bank loans are not just destroying small businesses – they even imperil the owners’ homes.  A shocking 30% of WBL’s real-estate loans result in default.  One in ten results in a formal foreclosure, and in many other cases, the small business owner is forced to sell their home.

The owner of a Georgia engineering services firm was threatened with foreclosure over a $55,000 loan at 88% APR. WBL prepared all of the documents Axos Bank (then known as BOFI Federal Bank) listed as the lender, and then an officer of WBL used a power of attorney for the bank to assign the loans to WBL. WBL sought $133,519 in interest and threatened to foreclose on the owner’s home.

Lenders are using these “rent-a-bank schemes” as a loophole more and more, originating the high-cost loans through a FDIC-regulated bank before buying them back in order to continue to charge exorbitant interest rates, according to CNBC, who reported on another example of this scheme with the fintech Elevate.

The “certainty” in the bright line test in the OCC’s rule comes at the cost of protecting evasive rent-a-bank schemes set up solely for the purpose of enabling destructive, usurious loans. Legitimate bank partnerships have a lot more bank involvement than a name on a piece of paper, and they do not need such a crude form of certainty. Indeed, the crude rule undermines incentives for banks to be actively involved in bank partnership programs.

Congress must act now to repeal the fake lender rule. As small businesses emerge from the devastating COVID crisis, they need a true helping hand, not predatory lending. 

David Levine is President of the American Sustainable Business Council.
Stephen Michael is the Executive Director of the Main Street Alliance.


This story and others on Times of E are made possible by a sponsorship from the Ewing Marion Kauffman Foundation. The Ewing Marion Kauffman Foundation is a private, nonpartisan foundation that provides access to opportunities that help people achieve financial stability, upward mobility, and economic prosperity – regardless of race, gender, or geography. The Kansas City, Mo.-based foundation uses its grantmaking, research, programs, and initiatives to support the start and growth of new businesses, a more prepared workforce, and stronger communities. For more information, visit www.kauffman.org and connect with www.twitter.com/kauffmanfdn and www.facebook.com/kauffmanfdn.

Tags: David LevineEntrepreneurship policiesStephen Michael
David Levine and Stephen Michael

David Levine and Stephen Michael

Related Posts

VC Spotlight: Aperture Venture Capital Focuses on Diverse Founders in Fintech

VC Spotlight: Aperture Venture Capital Focuses on Diverse Founders in Fintech

by Ellen Chang
June 5, 2023
0

Garnet Heraman is one of Aperture Venture Capital’s co-founders. Aperture Venture Capital has taken a different route to raise money...

Venture Capital Spotlight: Zane Venture Fund in Atlanta Focuses on Diverse Founders in Southeast U.S.

Venture Capital Spotlight: Zane Venture Fund in Atlanta Focuses on Diverse Founders in Southeast U.S.

by Ellen Chang
May 4, 2023
0

Shila Burney is the founder of Zane Access and the founding and managing partner of Zane Venture Fund. Shila Burney...

Venture Spotlight:  VEST Her Ventures In Oklahoma Focuses on Future of Work, Care Economy

Venture Spotlight: VEST Her Ventures In Oklahoma Focuses on Future of Work, Care Economy

by Ellen Chang
March 30, 2023
0

Erika Lucas is the founder of StitchCrew and VEST Her Ventures in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma. Photo: courtesy of VEST After spending several years...

Silicon Valley Bank And The Tyranny Of The Commons

Silicon Valley Bank And The Tyranny Of The Commons

by Seth Levine
March 29, 2023
0

opened zipper and dollar bill with binary code This post originally appeared on VC Adventure, Seth Levine's blog. Like many...

Black man in a suit

VC Spotlight: Living Cities Raising $100M Fund of Funds To Help Close Wealth Gap

by Elizabeth Macbride
March 17, 2023
0

Joe Scantlebury, CEO of Living Cities If capital runs the world, then people of color need to have a bigger...

Venture Spotlight: Cake Ventures Invests in Demographic Change

Venture Spotlight: Cake Ventures Invests in Demographic Change

by Ellen Chang
March 2, 2023
0

Monique Woodard is the founder of Cake Ventures. Photo: Brendan Mainini Founded in 2021, Cake Ventures invests in areas where...

Subscribe to Times of E’s Free Weekly Newsletter

Learn about the emerging ecosystem of diverse founders

Popular

  • Got Bloat? The Easier To Digest A2 Milk

    Got Bloat? The Easier To Digest A2 Milk

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Trailblazer: How Cotopaxi’s Founder Built a Cult Following and a $160M Salt Lake City-Based Company

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Top 20 U.S. University Entrepreneurship Competitions

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Venture Capital Returns Are More Skewed Than People Realize

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Venture Capital Spotlight: Zane Venture Fund in Atlanta Focuses on Diverse Founders in Southeast U.S.

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Recent

VC Spotlight: Aperture Venture Capital Focuses on Diverse Founders in Fintech

VC Spotlight: Aperture Venture Capital Focuses on Diverse Founders in Fintech

June 5, 2023

Newsletter: When Mansplainers Talk Guns; Princess School; Better Dairy Milk; & The Do-Nothing Movement

May 31, 2023
Editor’s Note:  One Guiding Principle for Bank Regulators

Editor’s Note: One Big Fallacy That Gets In The Way Of Gun Law Reform

May 31, 2023

Recommended

  • Health
  • Climate
  • Deep Tech
  • Finance
  • Education
  • Women Entrepreneurs
  • Mentorship
Problem Solved: TishWish Offers Affordable Shipping Materials for Small Business

Problem Solved: TishWish Offers Affordable Shipping Materials for Small Business

1 year ago

Weekly newsletter: Silicon Valley sociopaths, COVID blood prick and best entrepreneurship schools

3 years ago
  • About
  • Partner
  • Bespoke Research
  • Listening Tours​
  • Contact
  • Support Us
  • Privacy Policy

(703-966-7357)

© 2020 Mondial Publishing Inc. All Rights Reserved.

 
Facebook Twitter Linkedin
No Result
View All Result
  • Research
  • Finance
  • Women Entrepreneurs
  • New Builders
  • Ecosystem
  • Events
  • Newsletter
  • Editor’s Note

© 2022 Mondial Publishing Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Support Times of E

Times of E covers the emerging ecosystem of diverse founders.

With your support of our journalism, you will receive our weekly newsletter and one of these resources for free: 

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?